Knitting or Crochet for Beginners: Find Your Best Start

If you’re wondering whether to start with knitting or crochet for beginners, you’re not alone. Walking into a yarn shop for the first time can feel exciting—and a little overwhelming. Knitting, crochet, needles, hooks, yarn weights… it’s a lot.

This guide is here to help you slow down, get oriented, and choose a starting point that actually fits you. There’s no right or wrong place to begin. The best first project is the one that feels doable and enjoyable.

Step One: What do you want to make?

Before tools or yarn, start with the outcome. Different crafts shine at different things.

• Blankets, toys, textured fabrics → Crochet is often a great fit
• Garments, scarves, structured fabric → Knitting may feel more natural
• Not sure yet → That’s okay—keep going

Step Two: One tool or two?

Prefer to see it side by side? This short video does a great job showing the differences between knitting and crochet in action.

This question alone helps many beginners decide.

• Crochet uses one hook at a time
• Knitting uses two needles working together

Some people love the rhythm of two needles. Others prefer managing just one hook. Neither is better—just different.

Step Three: How do you like to learn?

Your learning style matters more than you think.

• Prefer clear steps and structure?
• Want something repetitive and relaxing?
• Like to experiment and see quick progress?

Your answers will point you toward the craft—and the first project—that feels supportive rather than frustrating.

Take the Fiber Feels Quiz

Use this short questionnaire to find your best starting point. You can answer it here, or fill out a printed version in the shop and bring it to the register for personalized guidance.

What Happens Next?

If you’re in the shop:

• Bring your completed questionnaire to the register
• We’ll help you choose beginner-friendly yarn and tools
• We’ll suggest next steps—at home resources or upcoming classes

If you’re online:

• Watch a short intro video for knitting or crochet
• Join a class when the timing feels right
• Purchase a private one-on-one session

Or—just come observe.

Every Friday afternoon from 3-6pm, we host Craft & Chill, an RSVP gathering where people work on their own projects, chat, and help one another. You don’t need supplies, experience, or a plan—just curiosity. View calendar https://theyarnyway.punchpass.com/calendar

Watching others make, ask questions, and troubleshoot in real time can make everything click. You’re welcome to sit, listen, and see what resonates before deciding what to try.